Browse Upper Hay Lake waterfront homes for sale near Pequot Lakes. Peaceful, standalone lake in the Brainerd Lakes area. New listings, September, 2026.

 Upper Hay Lake features a mix of charming seasonal cabins, family lake retreats, luxury waterfront homes, and year-round residences. Many properties offer mature pine trees, private docks, expansive lake views, and easy access to boating, fishing, swimming, and paddleboarding. The lake's protected bays and scenic shoreline create a peaceful setting while still providing convenient access to Crosslake, Pequot Lakes, and the Brainerd Lakes Area. Unlike its neighbor Lower Hay Lake, Upper Hay Lake is not part of the Whitefish Chain, offering buyers a self-contained, private lake experience without chain boat traffic passing through. All listings are pulled from current MLS data and updated regularly. 
Ready to sell your Upper Hay Lake home? Looking for a Realtor who covers the whole area? See all Brainerd Lakes real estate.